Is seeing believing in the age of AI?

Remember ‘Marty The Ferry Cat'? Supposedly he daily took the ferry, for years. The Ferry crew even built him his own seat. At least, that’s what the feelgood story told us.

Everyone wanted to believe it. Seeing is believing. But hey, no problem with that. Pictures that seemed to prove it was true were everywhere on the internet. So naturally people assumed the rather remarkable story must be true.
 
Some things didn’t quite add up though. The same cat took ferry rides in several far-flung places at the same time: like Maui, Galveston, Savannah and Boston.

Recently our adventurous cat miraculously appeared in Germany on one of Hamburg's ferries too. Who cares about long distances anyway (I certainly don't; our ‘Ferry Cat’ Marty neither).

Time for some global expansion he must have thought and went international.

The only thing is…

Marty The Cat never travelled any ferries — but his AI-generated image did.

The original source of the story couldn’t be traced. Researchers found countless Facebook posts repeating and resharing the story however.

Once enough people repeat something, any story starts to look like a fact.

Do pictures prove anything?
Certainly not in the age of AI. Photos can create impressions. Why would you let them mislead you?
 
What examples can you share to help others to recognize reality?

Is it true Budapest built solar-heated tunnel shelters to keep stray dogs from freezing ❄️ ? That heartwarming ❤️story was doing the rounds last winter.

It sounded like a fact. The images looked like a fact. Media and their audiences repeated it like a fact.

Minor detail...it wasn’t a fact.

The tunnels didn’t exist. The images were AI-generated.

Looking back, the pictures raised an eyebrow:

* Why did some supposedly 'stray dogs' wear collars?

* Why did so many ‘stray dogs' resemble pedigree show dogs?

* Why were so many dogs together behaving impeccably (instead of playing or fighting)?

Nothing is impossible. That “I stumbled upon this ruin in a remote mountain range-image”, is now easy to generate. No need anymore to risk your life flying over the Hindu Kush in an ancient Yak-40. Piloted by someone who looks suspiciously drunk.

The modern explorer doen’t need to face danger, discomfort, or uncertainty. The only thing you need to conquer is the Wi-Fi password.

You can generate any picture without “going local”. The menu of that authentic local restaurant includes quinoa (not to be confused with sheep brain floating in butter).

AI-generated images are absolutely indispensable for visualizing things that don’t exist yet:
like new roads or buildings, new interiors, new products, new campaigns, future cities or future traffic situations.

Making an idea visually tangible can make it much easier to ‘sell’.

As long as the distinction between visualizing an idea and passing it off as documentation of reality stays clear. Does it?


The problem isn't AI technology itself, but what we choose to do with it.

What’s your favourite application of AI-generated images? And where did it derail?Should you believe everything you see? How can you still recognize a fact in the age of artificially generated images?

Do you think before you judge?
Or do you judge too easily and too soon?

Previous
Previous

How much are you willing to invest to make something possible? 

Next
Next

Does following procedures equal results?