Why would someone else’s story be your limitation?

People facing all kinds of challenges are often quick to hear an ‘I ALSO know a similar story'. Whether they want to start a business, want to buy a house, want to change something, want to launch a new product, want an exclusive deal, chase a dream, cope with a loss and so on. 

Often an ALSO story isn't exactly motivating.

* “I ALSO know someone who started a business. Didn't succeed”.
* “A friend of mine ALSO tried that too. Lost everything.”                                                              * “I ALSO know someone who got divorced. Was miserable for years.”
* “My colleague ALSO went through the same thing. Difficult.”
* “My friend’s son is ALSO like your child. Challenging.”

The similarities are a bit of a stretch. Details and circumstances are different, causes are different, possibilities are different and so on. The stories are anything but inspirational. How hearing them is supposed to help anyone else is a mystery? Why would they share such stories? Sweet of course that people share their experiences and want to be helpful. The problem is that these ‘also’ stories are rarely actually helpful, relevant or have any predictive value for anyone's future. 

A tiny element of recognition is presented as relevant knowledge. But just because an example readily comes to mind doesn’t mean it’s genuinely comparable.
Why are those stories told? Does an ‘also’ story say more about the storyteller’s need for certainty than about the person hearing it? Is sharing an ‘also’ story their  way of dealing with uncertainty?

]The fact that these stories often have little or nothing to do with the situation at hand doesn’t seem to spoil the fun.

Instead of admitting that they don’t know what will happen, some reach for a familiar story. Does that make a situation feel more in control or make them feel more like an expert?

Should anyone prioritize predictability over exploration?

Why these ‘also’ stories?

Our brains tend to prioritise protection and predictability over exploration. So much for innovation.

We often prefer the familiar and find uncertainty harder to deal with than a known risk. It can increase stress, anxiety and avoidance behavior.

Harvard's economist Daniel Ellsberg demonstrated that we systematically respond hesitant to unknown possibilities. Even when the unknown option might offer a better outcome.

We often find uncertainty more uncomfortable than risk itself and prefer knowing the odds. Even when that doesn’t necessarily give us a better chance. A 50% chance of winning (when the odds are known), feels more comfortable than a gamble with unknown probabilities (but possibly larger results).

In everyday life, “That’s impossible” is often an emotional prediction, not a logical conclusion.

The biggest obstacle often turns out to be our perception of uncertainty,

rather than objective impossibility.

The Ellsberg Paradox can be seen everywhere. Some examples.

  • Investors choose familiar stocks over unfamiliar markets.

  • Doctors may favour established treatments over new approaches with less certain data.

  • Consumers trust familiar brands more than unfamiliar alternatives.

We tend to prefer known probabilities over unknown ones,

even when doing so is logically inconsistent.

It’s easy to believe in something once it has already worked. And perhaps we can believe that things might work a little better next time. Before anything has actually worked, however, hardly anyone believes it will.

A sense of control and predictability plays a crucial role in how we feel.

From the perspective of the Ellsberg Paradox, this makes perfect sense: people often prefer a known limitation over an unknown possibility.
Our brains like closed models. When something is new, ambiguous or difficult to imagine you often hear things like:

“I don’t know how.”
“Nobody does this.”
“What if it fails?”

In any organization that wants to change something ‘possibly impossible’ is quickly heard somewhere.

Saying ‘impossible’ is considerably more efficient than exploring all the options, tolerating uncertainty and reconsidering existing assumptions.

“That’s impossible” can be a quick mental shortcut.

In practice, when people say “It can’t be done”, they often mean:

“I don’t understand how yet.”
“It doesn’t fit my current mental model.”

With "impossible" is meant: feels unfamiliar + uncertain + uncomfortable.

New ideas almost always collide with existing mental models at first.

Our brains use heuristics: mental shortcuts, pattern recognition and lessons drawn from previous experience. These can work well, but they can also make us conservative when faced with unfamiliar possibilities.

We say “That’s impossible” surprisingly often

when what we actually mean is

“I can’t imagine how it could work at the moment”.

The practical difference is enormous.

A useful alternative question is:

“Under what conditions could it work?”

How well can we cope with uncertainty?

Experiments have shown that it isn’t simply uncertainty itself that matters, but how we experience it.

Research into known versus unknown risks demonstrates that people respond differently to familiar risks (such as driving a car) than to unfamiliar risks (such as new technologies).

Economist Frank Knight already distinguished between 1. risk (where probabilities are known) and 2. uncertainty (where probabilities are unknown). Ellsberg subsequently demonstrated experimentally that people genuinely respond differently to these two situations.

People tend to find unfamiliar risks more frightening,

even when they are statistically less dangerous.

Professor and researcher Paul Slovic of the University of Oregon demonstrated that we don’t assess risks purely rationally.

According to Slovic, a risk scores highly on the unknown dimension when it is new, cannot be directly observed, is unfamiliar to science or the general public, and is difficult to understand. Our feelings and perceptions play an important role assessing risks. He identified two major dimensions:

1. Dreaded risk (fear and threat)

Risks that feel catastrophic, potentially fatal or beyond our control.

For example: nuclear accidents.

2. Unknown risk

Risks that are new, invisible, poorly understood or whose consequences may only become apparent much later.

Examples include radiation, genetic engineering, AI or nanotechnology.

This unknown dimension strongly influences how dangerous something feels, regardless of its actual probability.

The less familiar a risk is,

the more dangerous we tend to think it is.

What matters most is often how frightening something feels, not necessarily how dangerous it actually is.

This helps to explain why people sometimes make seemingly irrational decisions about risks.

It also explains why we can be more frightened of new technologies than of driving, why invisible threats provoke strong reactions, and why people become suspicious when experts tell them that something is safe.

Slovic showed that risk perception can be more influential than statistics.

This is true for politics as well as media.

A small but mysterious risk can generate considerably more public anxiety than a much greater but already familiar risk.

Nuclear energy is a classic example.

Statistically, its risks may be relatively manageable. But it scores highly on several dimensions of perceived risk: the threat is invisible, potential damage may be delayed, and the consequences are easy to imagine as catastrophic.

As a result, people may perceive it as considerably more dangerous than everyday risks such as road traffic or air pollution.

Why the unknown feels uncomfortable

Research into ‘ambiguity aversion’, particularly the Ellsberg Paradox, shows that people prefer choosing a known probability (for example, 50%) over an unknown one (for example, anywhere between 0% and 100%).

Even when the unknown option might offer a better outcome, people tend to avoid it.

In other words, we often prefer an option with known odds over one with unknown odds, even when their expected outcomes are statistically identical.

A known 50% probability simply feels safer.

This goes beyond ordinary risk aversion. It challenges the idea that people always make decisions according to classical rational models.

When we say something is impossible, we often mean that it feels uncertain and uncomfortable.

That’s very different from something being objectively impossible.

Don’t let uncertainty become an excuse to give up

When it comes to ambitions whose feasibility is unpredictable, why assume they are impossible and give up too soon?

If you do nothing, nothing will happen for sure.

Wouldn’t it have been a terrible missed opportunity if I had given up too soon?

Pretending that we can control everything isn’t realistic. Nobody can.

The courage to let go of control is sometimes the only option.

Nobody wants to miss opportunities, do they?

The illusion of control

Pretending that we always have control can be costly. It can lead to unnecessary energy expenditure and missed opportunities.

Surely you’re not going to fall for the illusion of control?

Nobel Prize-winning psychologist Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky demonstrated how strongly our brains are inclined to maintain a sense of consistency and coherence. Predictability and a feeling of control help us make sense of the world.

When predictability comes at a price

We find unpredictability difficult because our brains experience less control.

This explains why we’re willing to pay more for familiar brands: they offer a sense of predictability. If you order a hamburger at McDonald’s, you know roughly what to expect.

Is the familiar option actually always better? You don’t know for sure, but you assume it is.

It can be costly however. What are you willing to invest to make something possible? 

To save cruise passengers the stress of interacting with locals, some cruise companies offer them their own driver in every port for $ 100. Costs of the exactly the same ride in a local taxi? $1...

On the cruise I one reluctantly attended (it was simply the ‘cheapest’ hotel in the Emirates), people were willing to pay a 100-fold (!) premium to avoid uncertainty. That's how expensive a tendency to avoid uncertainty can be.

Perhaps that’s also why every minute on that cruise ship seems so meticulously planned. Just when passengers are on the verge of dozing off, loudspeakers announced: “Tai Chi on Deck 2 starts in five minutes. Fifteen minutes later: “Limbo dancing starts in 30 minutes on Deck 3.

Floating around peacefully in the overcrowded swimming pool isn’t for long. Soon it was time for aqua gym. Naturally passengers were informed on the start via aforementioned loudspeakers. Nothing unpredictable happens.

Something being uncomfortable or unpredictable doesn’t make it impossible.

Ultimately, statements such as “That’s impossible” often have several things going on beneath the surface:

  • Avoidance of uncertainty.

  • Protection of social norms.

  • Generalising from previous experiences.

  • Saving cognitive effort.

  • Fear of loss or of losing face.

Recognising these mechanisms is a good starting point.

Not knowing how something will turn out,

isn’t the same as knowing that it cannot happen.

Perhaps the question isn’t only: “How much control do we want?”. But also: “What is our need for control costing us? Or “How much is our target audience willing to invest to reduce uncertainty”?

How often do you venture off your proverbial deck?

Are you open to innovation, change and development? Why don’t you step away from the familiar decks once in a while, just to see what happens?

Many ‘I know someone who…’ stories are well-intentioned.

But you don’t have to let them hold you back.

Next
Next

Should you let assumptions write your future?