Why activity isn’t the same as making progress.

Why would you confuse what is easy to count with what actually counts?

Investing time and energy in things that are easy to achieve and deliver visible results can earn you quick applause. Regardless of how much impact they actually have. But do they bring you any closer to your goal?

It would be a shame (wouldn’t it?) to be surrounded by happy people in the harbour because you’ve allowed everyone on board your ship; only to sink further down the line because you’ve overloaded it?

The visibility of progress in the short and long term often differs. We tend to want results we can see quickly. As a result, we sometimes focus on the appearance of progress in the short term and lose sight of the bigger picture.

We like completing things. Once something is done, we can get it out of our heads and stop spending energy on it. In many organisations, people are rewarded primarily for short-term results, whether through applause, recognition, bonuses or other incentives. Their contributions to longer-term ambitions often go unrecognised, so their attention tends to focus elsewhere.

Symbolic politics is perhaps the best-known example. It doesn’t necessarily bring you any closer to your goal, but it does allow you to tick boxes quickly. A visible signal is sent to the public: action is being taken. Yeah!

For example, you could cover a neighbourhood that is already perfectly safe with surveillance cameras to demonstrate that you take public safety seriously. Or fill a notoriously windless area with wind turbines to show just how environmentally conscious you are. Both may be rather pointless, despite the boxes you can tick along the way.

Ticking the box marked actively doing something is not the same as being effective and achieving a goal.

Long-term quality can also be overshadowed by the immediate, visible benefits of relatively trivial achievements. The average organisation likes to see results quickly, even when their significance is limited. A share price that rises today feels good. So does a cost reduction this quarter.

Go ahead, tick off those immediately visible tasks. At least you won’t have to think about them anymore, and you’ll have a good story to tell in your reports.

The notorious box-ticking manager often loves trivial details. After all, the focus is on the quantity of things that can be ticked off, rather than on the results actually achieved.

You can mentally tick off actions and quickly earn applause for them. But do they bring you any closer to a more distant goal?

Don’t be fooled by tick marks. Goals don’t automatically get any closer just because you’ve ticked a few boxes. People sometimes spend their time on relatively unimportant to-dos that do little to advance their bigger ambitions. They feel good about completing visible tasks — another box ticked, yeah! — while their actual goals remain exactly where they were.

How relevant are your actions to your goal?

For the box-ticking manager, the answer seems almost irrelevant. Meanwhile, the things that could make a real difference to achieving a goal — but are harder to capture in a neat little tick box — remain on the to-do list. Eventually, the conclusion that the goal is impossible to achieve may be drawn far too quickly.

A great deal of time, money and energy can be spent on peripheral issues and minor details. After all, these are often easy to change and easy to tick off.

But a boring story with perfect grammar is still a boring story. And a piece of sandpaper won’t turn a run-of-the-mill building into an architectural icon.

When clients aren’t happy with the advertising concepts presented by their creative agencies, relatively trivial changes are sometimes made. But a mind-numbing idea that wouldn’t sell a single thing won’t suddenly become a hit just because you change the font.

Details can matter, but they don’t guarantee results. The real question is: Are you doing the right things, or merely the things you can tick off most easily?

Are you aiming for quality and impact, or for the quantity of hours and resources spent?

“I got ten things done today” sounds much better than “I worked effectively towards one important goal today, but haven’t achieved it yet.”

It doesn’t really matter how trivial those ten things were. Mowing the lawn or clearing your inbox, for example, might feel satisfying. Working towards doubling sales or buying a house, on the other hand, may take a long time before you see the desired result.

For convenience, the relative importance of those ten completed tasks is often overlooked. The world won’t end if you leave your lawn unmowed or your inbox overflowing. But that number — ten — sticks in your mind.

This is how an organisation can end up spending considerable time and attention brainstorming the new colour of its office furniture instead of working towards doubling sales, cutting costs or improving efficiency.

At least the task of providing input on the colour of the curtains can be ticked off the to-do list.

The same applies in our personal lives. What would be a better use of your time: creating a social media post about your neighbour’s cooking skills, or learning a professional skill, a language or a musical instrument?

What would benefit an organisation more: endless discussions about the colour of the curtains, or a plan to double the number of customers, donors, voters or fans?

To-do lists can help us stay organised. But people often spend their time on relatively unimportant tasks that are easy to complete, even if they do little to advance their bigger goals. In some organisations, the number of completed to-dos is even translated into performance ratings and bonuses.

Meanwhile, the things that could make the biggest difference to achieving a goal — but are more difficult and time-consuming — remain on the to-do list.

Some organisations describe this as an obligation to make an effort, rather than an obligation to deliver results.

And so, the main priorities remain untouched while less important tasks and minor details get ticked off and receive a disproportionate amount of attention.

Are you spending most of your time on the right things?

Uncertainty often makes us uncomfortable. We prefer to have evidence that we’re in control, even when that control is an illusion.

We see trends where there is nothing but noise. It gives us a sense of control.

As Annie Duke explains in Thinking in Bets, we’re not particularly good at thinking in probabilities, so we mistake noise for signals.

Sometimes, we spend a disproportionate amount of time on a highly unlikely scenario that would be extremely profitable if it worked out. But perhaps we would achieve more by investing all that time and energy in the scenario with the highest probability of success.

In organisations, operationally minded box-ticking managers often like seeing lots of details ticked off. More goal-oriented managers can become increasingly frustrated when, despite all that operational diligence, the main objective remains stubbornly out of reach.

And that’s when the perception that the goal is impossible starts to take hold — even when the real problem is that people have been busy doing the wrong things.

“De olifant blijft te vaak op de to-do lijst staan en dat geeft stress, laat staan dat hij gevangen wordt, mensen zijn te slim om op konijnen te jagen. Verspil je energie niet aan jagen op konijnen als je  eigenlijk een olifant wil vangen”
— Elke Geraerts

Quality or quantity: What pays off?

What pays off more: investing in quality or quantity?

Of course, you need both. You can’t afford to neglect either one. But quantity is often easier to measure and more visible than quality. As a result, it tends to receive a disproportionate amount of attention.

So, what pays off more?

QUALITY. Investing in the kind of animals you catch — lions or elephants, for example?

QUANTITY. Or investing in the number of animals you catch, regardless of what they are or how easy they are to catch? Ants, for instance, are a lot easier to catch than elephants.

What can organisations do about this?

Don’t become fixated on numbers. Look at both quality and quantity.

Ask yourself:

  • Are managers sufficiently focused on outcomes rather than on the number of operational odds and ends completed and ticked off their lists?

  • Are important tasks being done properly, with quality in mind, or are they being rushed through to the bare minimum, simply so they can be marked as ‘done’ on a to-do list?

It’s a choice. At the very least, make it a conscious one.

“Most of what we say and do is not essential… Ask yourself at every moment; ‘Is this necessary?”
— Marcus Aurelius


Previous
Previous

Making the “impossible” possible

Next
Next

When Milestones become destinations: the hidden cost of giving up too soon