Should you quit before you’ve even begun?

“Are you sure that’s such a good idea?”

Whenever you want to try something new, you are often met with a tsunami of well-meant pieces of advice. Some are genuinely valuable. Others sound more patronising than encouraging. But do good intentions automatically make them helpful?

Where do they come from? Does the confidence with which someone delivers their opinion say anything about how accurate their advice actually is? Should we take every piece of advice seriously? And does dismissing it make anyone ungrateful?

Why do we warn each other?

Most people like to feel they are doing something useful for others. I’m no exception. Offering a warning is an easy way to show that you care and are thinking along. Sounds thoughtful, doesn’t it?

But not every opinion is based on knowledge however. Warning someone is easy. All you have to do is point out what might go wrong. Anyone can think of a possible obstacle and be dramatic about it.

Why are we so easily discouraged?

But surely humans are critical thinkers?

If only. We tend to think we’re much more critical than we actually are. It’s human nature: we overestimate not only how consciously we think, but also how much we really know. More often than not, our knowledge is far less extensive than we imagine.

Yale researchers Leonid Rozenblit and Frank Keil explored how easily we overestimate our own knowledge. They called this the illusion of explanatory depth: the feeling that we understand something well. In reality, we’re simply familiar with it. Before we know it, a little familiarity starts to feel like expertise.

Nobel Prize-winning psychologist Daniel Kahneman explained in his book Thinking, Fast and Slow how we all rely on two different modes of thinking. Fast, intuitive thinking (‘System 1’) and slower, more deliberate reasoning (‘System 2’).

We simply don’t have time to think everything through. Imagine having to reconsider whether to stop every single time you approach a busy road. Fortunately, System 1 (our mental autopilot), takes care of many everyday decisions.

Assumptions are one of System 1’s mental shortcuts: quick and convenient, but not necessarily delivering the right answers. Not every question has a simple, straightforward answer.

Should we dismiss an ambitious plan simply because nobody has done it before? Reject an innovative idea because it doesn’t fit existing ways of working? Assume a woman isn’t ambitious enough?

These questions call for something other than snap judgments. They require the more effortful reasoning of System 2, which can challenge and expose the weaknesses in our initial assumptions.

The problem is that deliberate thinking with system 2 takes energy. As a result, we don’t use for everything, even though we like to think we do.

How many opportunities are we missing?

Things get tricky when the distinction between a genuine risk and a personal assumption becomes blurred. Sometimes nobody knows what will happen. No matter how confidently someone claims otherwise.

Do you give something a try or not after being confronted with those assumptions? Do you persevere or give up?

If inventors had always given up at the first sign of doubt, very little would ever have changed.

How do we stop assumptions from holding us back?

A warning often says as much about the person giving it as it does about the person receiving it.

Psychological research into tolerance of uncertainty highlights individual differences in how comfortable people are with the unknown. Someone who prefers certainty and predictability is unlikely to be enthusiastic about your uncertain ambitions. Someone else might see exactly the same uncertainty as an exciting challenge.

Before taking a warning at face value, consider where it comes from. Is it based on knowledge, experience or evidence? Or does it reflect someone’s personal discomfort with uncertainty?

Ask yourself one simple question:

Do we know something is (im)possible, or do we merely think it is?

Don’t let assumptions close doors unnecessarily. Don’t give up before you’ve even tried.

‘Confidence’ isn’t the same as ‘evidence’. And ‘unpredictable’ doesn’t equal ‘impossible’.

Previous
Previous

Never give up too soon.

Next
Next

Consultantouflage. Aka the world's most confusing job title.