Consultantouflage. Aka the world's most confusing job title.

Words immediately create expectations. One word tells you what's reasonable to expect. You wouldn’t go to a dentist with a sprained ankle or visit an ophthalmologist because you have a cold.

Nomen est omen. The best brand names, such as Cup-a-Soup or Chocomel, immediately tell you what you’re getting. So expecting a job title to do the same doesn’t seem that far-fetched.

Yet the content of jobs carried out under the label 'consultant' can differ enormously.

Clear job titles help people to understand in a few words what people actually do, what expertise they bring and what they can reasonably be expected. You wouldn't visit your dentist to buy flowers; no one would ever take you seriously again.

It gets complicated when different people have different associations and expectations of the same words. When there obviously is a gap between what different people understand that a word means. Different meanings, different expectations. When definitions clash, mutual irritation is almost inevitable.

One word whose meaning seems almost infinitely elastic is consultant. It’s used almost as broadly as vegetables or meat. No wonder people struggle to pin down what it actually means.

In one organization, an advisor may be expected to challenge assumptions, develop ideas and influence decisions. In another, the role may involve following established procedures and just implementing decisions made elsewhere.

  • At a consultancy firm, a consultant is generally someone with specialist knowledge, who is hired by clients to solve complex problems and make things possible. That’s what clients want to pay for.

  • In some organizations 'in-house Consultant' (whatever the topic) is little more than an impressive-sounding job title. The same title can mean entirely different things in different organizations. Some in-house consultants are brilliant, but the content of their work has little to do with 'consultancy' as consulting firms know it.

  • Some in-house consultants have an amount of expertise that would make Einstein look like an amateur. Yet mysteriously enough they aren’t involved when decisions are made about the very subjects they know so much about. Just nod and agree. Apparently, that’s the job. Confusing.

'Consultants' who move from a consultancy firm to an in-house role are often baffled to discover that they’re apparently suddenly expected to switch their brains off and produce stickers and fold paperclips as well.

This creates a particularly puzzling situation in recruitment. Job titles are interpreted by some candidates to suggest thinkers are sought, while organizations actually want yes-men executors without opinions. Confusing.

As a result job interviews feel like a modern-day Tower of Babel to all participants: everyone appears to speak the same language, yet nobody means the same thing.

A word about the brand name ‘advisor’.

What exactly is a 'consultant'? Someone who thinks independently and offers expert advice? Or simply a senior Bokito in the corporate monkey pit?

The title remains the same. The expectations couldn’t be more different.

What are your experiences? Have you encountered impressive job titles that turned out to mean something entirely different in practice?


Previous
Previous

Should you quit before you’ve even begun?

Next
Next

The power of words & images in shaping what’s possible.