What can leaders learn from theatre makers?

Leaders want to innovate, embrace new technologies and adapt to changing circumstances. They launch transformation programmes, set ambitious goals and encourage employees to think differently, right?

Yet many initiatives never get off the ground. Some lose momentum, get stuck in endless discussions or quietly disappear when the first obstacles emerge.

Why?

David Linssen helps organisations to bring innovation to life. He points to a fundamental tension for boardroom and leaders: organizations need to keep their current operations running smoothly, while simultaneously developing something new.

The first requires predictability, control and reliability. The second requires experimentation, uncertainty and a willingness to deviate from established routines.

And that’s precisely the challenge.

Employees learn are often rewarded for following procedures, meeting targets, sticking to budgets and keeping things under control. Hence they avoid mistakes, follow established procedures and focus on delivering predictable results.

Then their leaders ask them to innovate.

But how can you expect people to experiment, when they know they’ll be held accountable for every unexpected outcome? Why would they take a risk if sticking to the familiar is the safer choice?

You can’t reward people for avoiding uncertainty,

and then expect them to embrace it anyway when innovation apparently became a priority.

Declaring something impossible can be surprisingly comforting.

If an idea is dismissed before it is tested, nobody has to risk failing. No uncomfortable questions need to be asked. No established routines need to be challenged. And nobody has to explain why the experiment didn’t work.

The organisation can carry on as usual.

Of course, not every idea is good. Not every project deserves to continue, and not every ambition is achievable. Recognising that is part of making sound decisions.

But there’s a crucial difference between concluding that something won’t work after investigating it and deciding that it can’t work before giving it a proper chance.

Uncertainty (and unpredictability) isn’t proof of impossibility.

A lack of precedent doesn’t necessarily mean an idea is unrealistic. It simply means nobody has tried it before.

Innovation requires room to play

David Linssen draws an interesting parallel with theatre-making.

When a theatre director starts working on a production, actors and set designers are encouraged to explore ideas without immediately worrying about whether they’ll work.

No idea is too crazy to try.

Only later does the director select the ideas that work, refine them and bring everything together into a coherent performance.

Imagine if the rehearsal process worked differently. What if every suggestion had to be justified in advance? What if actors were criticised for trying something that didn’t work? What if the director demanded a predictable outcome before allowing anyone to experiment?

The result would hardly be groundbreaking theatre.

Organisations face the same challenge. They need to create environments where people can explore possibilities without the fear of being punished for every unsuccessful attempt.

That doesn’t mean abandoning accountability or letting everyone do whatever they please. It means distinguishing between reckless behaviour and thoughtful experimentation.

You cannot discover what works if you aren’t allowed to try or if experimenting isn’t rewarding

If organizations genuinely want innovation, they need to look beyond inspiring presentations, brainstorming sessions and colourful Post-it notes.

Are employees also encouraged to challenge assumptions and experiment? Can they admit that something isn’t working without being blamed? Are experiments evaluated on what the organisation learns, rather than simply on whether they succeed?

And what happens when a project encounters difficulties?

Sometimes, stopping is the right decision. But sometimes, a project is abandoned because experimentation feels uncomfortable.

The answer isn’t to persevere at all costs. A culture is required in which people can acknowledge uncertainty, experiment and change course without automatically being labelled failures.

Different ambitions require different people

David Linssen also highlights the importance of having different types of people involved in innovation.

Pioneers explore new possibilities. Builders turn promising ideas into workable business models. City planners help scale those models and make them repeatable.

All three are essential, but they don’t necessarily thrive under the same management approach.

Pioneers need room to explore. Builders need room to develop and test workable solutions. City planners need to establish structures that make successful approaches sustainable.

Treat everyone as though their job is to maintain predictable operations, and you risk losing the very people who could help your organisation move forward.

Innovation needs more than ambitious goals.

It needs people who can explore possibilities,

in an environment that allows them to experiment,

and a system that helps successful ideas take root.

It’s not about pretending that everything is possible. Nor about ignoring risks or refusing to accept reality.

It’s about recognising the difference between a genuine limitation and an assumption that has never been tested.

It’s about refusing to let uncertainty and unpredictability make your decisions for you.

And it’s about recognising how easily people and organisations can talk themselves out of possibilities before they’ve even explored them.

Sometimes, you need to persevere. Sometimes, you need to change your approach. Sometimes, you need to stop.

But before you give up, ask yourself:

Have we established that this won’t work? Or do we simply assume it probably won’t?

Don’t confuse unpredictable with impossible.

Don’t let an untested assumption become the reason you’ll never find out what might have been possible.

What about you?

Have you ever seen an ambition or change project abandoned too soon because someone decided it couldn’t be done?

Or have you experienced the opposite: a seemingly impossible idea that became reality because someone refused to give up too soon?

Previous
Previous

Why would you let opinions stop you?

Next
Next

Do you practice what you preach?