We constantly try to LEGO-fy our world. The simpler something looks, the more predictable it seems. Simplified 'mental boxes' offer the comfort of a handrail in an uncertain world.
Dark skies = rain ahead. Quiet person = shy. Young people = lack of experience. Look healthy = be fine. Not smiling = unhappy. No reply = someone is ignoring you. Feels difficult = must be impossible. Looking unfamiliar = unsuitable. Work hard = success guaranteed.
But are our simple assumptions also true?
Fake certainty is like a drug. Temporarily it makes you feel better.
But in the long run, it doesn’t improve anything.
Oversimplification and illusory predictability don’t make a blindfold transparent. What we think is true, shapes our decisions however. It nfluences what we think, see as possible and guides our behavior. That’s why the content of our 'mental boxes' matte
Fake comfort isn't gonna help you to be more effective, increase profits or simply make better decisions. Honest uncertainty beats confident assumptions. If you want better results, at least.
Oversimplified assumptions can become quite personal.
Suddenly I was the one being squeezed into other people’s dead-end mental boxes. Yikes.
While making what felt like a miraculous recovery from a stroke (more about that here https://lnkd.in/p/exWtna6Q ), I experienced how other people’s tendency to put me in wonderfully unwanted and (needless to say not exactly flattering) ‘mental boxes’, sometimes became a bigger challenge than physically recovering itself. Tiresome.
Suddenly, I had apparently moved from the box 'headstrong cultured globetrotters' to the box 'poor things who need nannying'. This inspired some people to talk to me as if I were three years old. Strange.
When facts are less persistent than assumptions.
The mental boxes of some others didn’t seem to have an expiry date. True, for two months I had looked like roadkill bird and even couldn’t walk. Luckily, it was only temporary.
Wasn’t the fact that I was recovering again more important than clinging to their assumptions? Apparently not.
No one expects the road back from the edge to be a smooth ride. But what kind of parade of absurdity was this? Did I really need to waste the little energy I had back then explaining that temporarily not being able to move or speak, isn’t the same as not being able to think anymore in the future?
Nevertheless, almost a year later I still received emails from near-strangers who said things like: “It must be difficult not being able to walk anymore”. Very difficult, I imagine. Except that I could walk again for ages already. I guess their mental labels couldn't wait.
Phantom barriers
There were many things I could have been left with after the stroke. Miraculously, nothing had happened to my brain. But what I had underestimated was that thinking isn’t visible. Struggling vocal cords and muscles were.
You might think: "You were extremely lucky. So move on". Guess what? That’s exactly what I thought too.
However while I was still slowly recovering, some people apparently drew their own conclusions. "If your muscles aren't cooperating perfect yet, your brain must have stopped working too". Sigh.
What people believed to be true had real-world consequences.
The most difficult barriers weren’t the tangible ones. They were the problems that didn’t actually exist — except in other people’s minds.“You must have difficulty thinking now, so this role will be too difficult for you". Well, actually, I never had any difficulty to think sharply. They rolled their eyes when I told them.
Temporary 'in-between' situations were mistaken for permanent realities. In the minds of some people I was apparently 'frozen in a moment' I had already moved beyond a long time ago.
They mistook the snapshots they had for a live feed. Their label outlived the reality it was meant to describe. Again their mental labels couldn't wait.
To hell with oversimplification.
My story explains my allergy to oversimplification — to put it mildly. Enough about be because this isn’t about me either. It’s about the power — and danger — of overly simplistic mental boxes.“There’s no market for that", "It’s already been tried“, "That idea is impossible to realize.” "This will never work or be profitable". "Hiring that person its a risk". "That project will fail".
When we let assumptions guide our decisions, they can quietly turn into barriers. Look at many ambitions or projects. People mistake their assumptions about possibilties for simplified facts.
We make choices based on the maps in our heads: whether we pursue an idea, a business plan or a change, who we vote for, what we choose to study or who to spend time with. Are our 'mental boxes' built on actual facts — or outdated assumptions we mistake for facts?
What we think is true isn’t always the same as what is true. For individuals, businesses and organizations, the gap between the two can become an unnecessary barrier — and a source of missed opportunities.
Sounding certain doesn’t make an action effective. And being confidently wrong rarely makes it profitable.
Also mental boxes have an expiry date.
Markets change. Technology changes. Social norms change. Expired wrong assumptions can become a source of missed opportunities — for businesses, organizations and individuals.
Non-alcoholic beer is a great example. Not long ago, drinking 0.0% beer was seen as something for party poopers ("Just trail your hand along the guardrail and drive after you drank anyway").
Today, social norms have changed. Drinking non-alcoholic beer is seen as the obvious choice when you’re driving. Although the fact that 0,0% beer no longer tastes like ditch water certainly helps.
The problem with assumptions is that they can turn yesterday’s reality into tomorrow’s constraint.
What if “There’s no market for that” really means “there wasn’t a market for that — yet”? What if it just means "there's a blank spot on the map — one we haven’t explored yet"? What if “That’s impossible” just means: "We haven’t found the key to that door yet"?
Some ideas once seemed unrealistic. Their inventors weren’t taken very seriously. Then they turned out to be right anyway. Suddenly, they were neatly moved into the mental box labelled 'geniuses'. We’re quick to stamp something as 'impossible' — and just as quick to stamp it 'genius' once it works.
Dialysisinventor Dr. Willem Kolff was categorized as a 'true visionary' — rather than an 'eccentric inventor' — once he succeeded in cleansing blood outside the body.
When Melanie Perkins and Cliff Obrecht set out to make design accessible to everyone, numerous investors said no. Eventually, Canva was funded anyway. Suddenly, Melanie and Cliff were not labelled as 'maverick entrepreneurs' but as 'unicorn founders'.
Before his technology became a household name, James Dyson went through years of failure and built 5,126 prototypes. Today, it would seem rather strange to put him in the mental box of 'stubborn inventors'.
Don't let assumptions but true insights guide you.
Real insight rocks. You better start with radical target group research if you want to influence people. What drives people and what inhibits them? What are the alternatives they can choose from? How can you win their choice and change their behavior?
Things change.
The pictures in our heads don’t always change with them.
It’s a bit like meeting an aunt when you’re five years old and seeing her again at forty — only to find her genuinely surprised that you no longer look like the toddler she remembers. Somehow, that toddler is still the version of you she has in her head. It’s as if someone forgot to install every update along the way.
Wrong assumptions can send us down the wrong road — and make us spend money getting there.
Simplification isn't the same as oversimplification. There is a difference between making something complicated easier to understand and making something complicated appear simpler than it really is.
The problem starts when an opinion or guess is presented as a fact.
When nobody stops to check where an assumption ends and a fact begins, the consequences can be costly. Sometimes, we don’t even try something, because we assume it is impossible anyway. Or businesses spend precious time and money solving the wrong problem.
And a simple, easy-to-digest opinion is often better for your image — and more memorable — than saying, “I don’t know yet. It’s complicated.”
Populists know a simple story people want to hear is catchy — even when it’s complete nonsense. Voters love it. But an assumption doesn’t become a fact simply because it's simple and enough people repeat it.
Sometimes reality is more complicated than a simple story we have in our heads.
For a while, I spent a lot of time in Mumbai, India. “It must be so difficult to be there — so many poor and uneducated people", some Dutch friends stressed emphatically. Sure, Mumbai is no Disneyland and being a foreigner there isn’t easy. But the idea that everyone there is uneducated? That certainly wasn’t my experience.
Thanks to India’s universities, Big Tech has access to some brilliant engineers. Some digital tools are also more widely used there than in the Netherlands. And what some people might simply call a “slum” is also home to incredibly smart and resilient entrepreneurs. Should you avoid going there because of a biased view? You’d be missing out. As a matter of fact, I love India.
It turned out to be the same in every country I visited. Many of the assumptions I arrived with turned out to be terribly wrong.
When assumptions derail.
During what felt like an agonizingly slow recovery — which by medical standards, appeared to be bizarrely fast — it became quite tiresome to be repeatedly put into boxes belonging to stations I had passed a long time ago. Apparently, the tam-tam hadn’t got the message yet.
Poor people. The suitable box kept changing all the time. I felt like I’d been knocked out in a boxing match — multiple times in a row. Recovery was a bit like a slowly self-deflating ball gradually regaining its shape. Slow as hell, but real. But apparently, people’s 'mental boxes' couldn’t wait. What box could they put me in tomorrow? That was the question. Who knew. Challenging.
Something similar happens in organizations all the time. Something goes wrong in a project. A deadline is missed. An approach fails. And before you know it, the goal itself is declared impossible.
One setback. One assumption. One new mental box: “impossible.”
But a setback is not necessarily proof that a destination is unreachable. Sometimes, it’s simply proof that a particular way of getting there doesn’t work. But does that really mean it can’t be done?
It’s like taking a wrong turn and concluding that the destination doesn’t exist.
A confident opinion feels much better. And that’s where assumptions become dangerous.
An honest “I don’t know yet” leaves room to change course. A confident assumption can turn a wrong turn into a destination.
Sometimes the biggest obstacle between an idea and a desired result isn’t the idea itself, but the assumptions underneath it.
We all put people and situations in 'mental boxes'; consciously or not. I’m definitely no exception. These 'mental boxes' quickly give us a sense of order and predictability — something to hold on to.
Even when we don’t really know, we tend to assume that someone who looks poor must also be poor. But how do we know someone isn't actually a millionaire? “What You See Is All There Is”, as Nobel Prize-winning psychologist Daniel Kahneman put it. If we don’t see anything that suggests otherwise, we tend to assume we’re right — and rarely give our chosen boxes a second thought.
Sometimes a prototype doesn’t work. That doesn’t mean the underlying idea is worthless. We turn temporary circumstances into permanent labels because uncertainty is uncomfortable. Saying “I don’t know yet” apparently feels unsatisfying.
Don't decide too early something isn’t possible. Is 'not successful now' the same as 'not possible in the future'?
A company struggles. A product fails. And suddenly, people seem to know how the story ends."It won’t work. Maybe we should be realistic".Really? How exactly did we become so good at predicting the future from one temporary situation? Or predicting a whole movie from a single frame?
A great example are the Post-it notes we all know. The adhesive that eventually made them possible was initially considered a failure, because it wasn’t particularly strong. It took someone looking at the same 'failed' invention differently to see a useful application.
The point isn’t that every failed idea eventually becomes a success. The point is we shouldn't give up too soon.
Some people immediately start imagining the worst case however. "Maybe it won't work'" But they don’t know that.
Take Vine. This short-form video platform initially became hugely popular, but Twitter (now X) shut it down in 2017. A few years later, TikTok had turned short-form video into a global phenomenon.
Was Vine a stupid idea? Apparently not. Perhaps it was simply too early? Or perhaps the people running didn't it did't have the required patience and budgets?
When something isn’t working yet, we have a remarkable tendency to conclude that it won’t ever work.
We confuse 'not successful now' with 'impossible to become successful'. Those aren’t the same thing. The future has the annoying habit of making our confident conclusions look rather premature.
Why would you start with wrong assumptions?
Sometimes brands try to connect with social movements. A company may reason: 'Consumers care about this issue. Therefore our brand should say something about it'.
But knowing that a target group considers an issue important does not automatically mean that group also expects your brand to comment on it. Some people may appreciate the statement. Others may see it as opportunistic marketing.
Starting with wrong assumptions also happened with BIC’s infamous attempt to market pens specifically to women. The logic seemed simple: "We have identified a target group, therefore we should adapt the product for that group".
But the underlying need was never convincingly researched. Did women actually want a 'women’s pen'? The resulting product was widely mocked online. The problem wasn’t necessarily a lack of creativity. It was a lack of true insight.
Sometimes an assumption becomes the strategy before anyone has actually established whether it is true.
Why wouldn't you have the courage to say “I don’t know" more often”?
Sometimes a company or person isn’t succeeding yet. That doesn’t mean it can’t succeed later.
Maybe the question isn’t:
“Do we believe this will work?”
but:
“What do we actually know — and what are we simply assuming?”
Perhaps we should become much more comfortable with saying: “I don’t know.”
We should become better at distinguishing between what we know and what we simply assume.
Sometimes assuming and betting is all we can. Admitting uncertainty leaves room for something much more interesting: possibility.
Sometimes the most intelligent answer isn’t a simplistic checkbox. It’s a question mark.
P.S.
In 2019, Danish broadcaster TV 2 Danmark created the iconic television spot All That We Share.
It showed how quickly we put people into boxes — and how easily those boxes start to shape the way we see things.
Funny how our mental boxes can change when reality proves us wrong.
Apples iconic 'Think different' campaign https://lnkd.in/p/ewGhATip nailed exactly that phenomenon.